Skip Navigation

How to Choose a Surety Bond Company

Specialized surety agencies can offer you the most options and save you money because they work with more surety companies (insurance companies).


  (updated: August 23, 2017)

What is a Surety Bond Company?

Most people are under the impression that when they contact a bond specialist or insurance agent to assist with a surety bonding need, they are speaking with the surety company. In reality, you are speaking with a bond agent or broker. 

A Surety Company is an Insurance Company that Issues Surety Bonds

Surety companies are insurance companies that underwrite and issue bonds. Not all insurance companies are surety companies. Surety companies contract with agents to represent the company by advertising its rates and handling the customer service and management part of the surety bond life cycle. Except in rare cases, surety companies do not deal directly with surety bond buyers.

What is a Surety Agent or Broker?

Get quotes from a specialized surety agency like Surety Bonds Direct that automatically searches multiple surety insurance companies for you. 

A surety agent (or broker) is an insurance agent that is properly licensed and properly appointed with surety bond companies. There are many differences between surety and insurance and there are specialized surety agents that understand bond requirements, bond eligibility, and bond-specific underwriting. 

Specialized surety agencies are typically appointed with surety companies that most traditional property and casualty agents cannot access which allows customers access to a broader range of options. 

Your surety agent's role is to find the best surety company for you to work with to get your bond. Surety specialists will know which surety companies offer the most competitive rates for the specific bond you need and should check with multiple surety companies to compare rates for you. The surety agent will guide you through the process to purchase your bond and will act on behalf of the surety company to issue your bond to you.

The surety agent will continue to serve as your representative for any changes made to the bond, but the agent is not part of the 3-party agreement of the surety bond. The agent is the "go between" for you (the principal) and the surety company. 

Agents vs Brokers: What's the Difference?

There is no practical difference between the terms "agent" and "broker" for the principal (you). The term agent is a broader term historically meant to reference a representative of the insurance company and the term broker usually implies that the agent has a variety of appointments with different insurance companies and represents the buyer. Surety Bonds Direct, and almost all specialized surety agencies are referred to as brokers within the industry because they work with a wide variety of surety companies.

What Does the Surety Bond Company Do?

The surety company is actually just one of the parties to a surety bond and its primary role in the bonding process can be described as follows:

Evaluate the Surety Bond Types

The surety company determines what surety bond types or liabilities that it wants to assume. Like any other business, the surety company makes this decision based on expected profitability. A surety company makes money on a surety bond type or class when its total bond premiums collected exceed the sum of losses paid for claims, operating costs and commissions paid for a particular bond type.

Establish Bond Pricing and File rates

How Much do Surety Bonds Cost?For more information on bond prices, see
How Much Do Surety Bonds Cost?

The surety company first must determine if it wants to participate in the market for a certain type of surety bond. This typically involves internal actuarial work, historical analysis on potential claim activity and a review of competitors offering the bond. Once a surety company makes a decision to offer a type of surety bond, they must get the bond pricing approved by the state insurance departments where they plan to sell these bonds. This process is referred to rate filings. Different rates or prices will be approved based on different applicant risk and bond risk profiles.

Underwrite Each Individual Application

The underwriting process involves establishing the appropriate rate tier or pricing for each individual surety bond application. The process usually involves a review of the applicants credit history, industry experience and other factors that may be needed as part of the bonding process. The underwriting process is typically handled by a surety company underwriter or in some cases by the bond specialist agency. For some surety bond types, the underwriting function is completely automated, allowing for instant pricing.

Surety Bond Claims Management

In the event of a claim filed against a surety bond, the surety company will investigate the claim to determine the validity of the claim. If the claim is determined to be valid based on the provisions of the bond (and it can't be resolved by the bonded principal), the surety company will usually be responsible for compensating the damaged party for financial losses including legal costs. The liability of the surety company is typically limited to the bond penalty. In most cases, the bonded principals have provided their indemnity to the surety company as part of the bond application. This means that they are responsible for reimbursing the surety company for losses paid due to unresolved claims.

What to Look for in a Surety Company?

While your agent rather than the surety company is your point of contact for the surety bond process, there are still some important criteria that you want in your surety company. After all, as discussed above, the surety company is standing behind your bond so you want to make sure the surety company is reputable and financially strong. The following criteria are what to look for to make sure you have the right company. Your bond specialist or agent should be able to provide the information on the surety company that will issue your surety bond. Always talk with your agent to make sure the surety company that will write your bond meets these criteria.

Financially Sound

You want your surety company to be financially sound with the ability to meet its obligations. The largest surety companies in the world are Travelers, Liberty Mutual Group, Zurich Insurance Group, and CNA Surety (aka Western Surety) so from a financial perspective, you are in good hands with these companies. That said, there are several very good specialty surety companies in the market. While not as large, these specialty surety companies meet the financial strength requirements and have the added benefit of surety bonds being their core business.

The best way to ensure that a specialty surety company is credible is to ask your agent to provide the company's A.M. Best rating. A.M Best is considered to be the premier authority for insurance company credit rating. Look for surety companies with an A (Excellent) A.M. Best rating. Standard & Poor's (S&P) also provides independent financial information, analytical services, and credit ratings.

Licensed and Authorized

Make sure your surety company is licensed and authorized to transact business in your state. Must state insurance departments provide online resources to verify licensing in the status in the state. It is also a good idea to confirm that the surety company is on the U.S. Department of Treasury’s Listing of Certified Companies.

Get a Surety Bond

Surety Bonds Direct is a national specialized surety agency with customer-service focus. We only work with AM Best A Rated carriers. Read reviews from our customers. 

Ready to get started? Take 2 minutes to request your bond. We'll compare rates from multiple surety companies and get back to you ASAP with the best rate. There's no obligation. Get started with your free quote.

I Want a Free, No-Obligation Bond Quote